liverpool player ratings vs plymouth: federico chiesa, diogo jota, and luis diaz flop spectacularly as reds suffer humiliating fa cup defeat to rock-bottom championship strugglers
Table of Contents
In a jaw-dropping FA Cup fourth-round clash, Liverpool suffered a humiliating 1-0 defeat to Championship basement-dwellers Plymouth Argyle. The Reds, currently topping the Premier League, were expected to cruise through this fixture. However, football’s unpredictability reared its head, leaving Liverpool fans in disbelief.
A Night Of Defeat, A Night to Forget: Liverpool’s Lackluster Performance
Liverpool’s lineup, though rotated, still boasted talents like Diogo Jota, Luis Díaz, and Federico Chiesa. Despite this, the team failed to gel, producing a disjointed display that lacked urgency and cohesion. The Reds managed only a handful of shots on target, rarely troubling Plymouth’s defense.

The Decisive Moment: Elliott’s Costly Handball
The game’s turning point came early in the second half. Harvey Elliott, attempting to block a cross, inadvertently handled the ball inside the box.
The referee had no hesitation in pointing to the spot. Plymouth’s Ryan Hardie stepped up and coolly slotted the penalty past Caoimhin Kelleher, sending the home fans into raptures.
Plymouth’s Heroics: A Defensive Masterclass
Credit must be given to Plymouth’s resolute defense. Goalkeeper Conor Hazard was in inspired form, making several crucial saves to preserve his clean sheet.
Defenders Nikola Katic and Maksym Talovierov were rock-solid, thwarting Liverpool’s attacking forays time and again.

Player Ratings: Who Flopped and Who Fought?
- Caoimhin Kelleher (6/10): Made a couple of important saves but was left exposed for the penalty.
- James McConnell (5/10): Struggled defensively and offered little going forward.
- Jarell Quansah (5/10): Looked shaky under pressure and was often out of position.
- Kostas Tsimikas (4/10): Failed to provide width and was defensively suspect.
- Wataru Endo (6/10): Worked hard in midfield but couldn’t influence the game.
- Harvey Elliott (4/10): His handball led to the penalty; otherwise ineffective.
- Trey Nyoni (5/10): Showed glimpses of talent but was largely anonymous.
- Federico Chiesa (3/10): A night to forget; lost possession frequently and lacked creativity.
- Diogo Jota (4/10): Failed to make an impact; missed a clear chance late on.
- Luis Díaz (4/10): Couldn’t get into the game; well-marshaled by Plymouth’s defense.

Looking Ahead: A Wake-Up Call for the Reds
This shocking exit serves as a stark reminder of football’s unpredictability. Liverpool must regroup quickly as they continue their pursuit of Premier League glory and European success. Complacency can be costly, and this defeat will undoubtedly prompt introspection within Arne Slot’s squad.
One Response
Well Slot was to be blamed, why such unprofessional team selection?